What is the Rule of Law?
-
The Rule of Law Wheel is a visual tool to explain the key principles that underpin a society governed by the rule of law. It breaks down complex legal ideas into four clear layers and helps students and the public understand how these elements work together to protect rights, limit power, and uphold justice.
-
This video outlines the underlying elements of the rule of law as fairness, rationality, predictability, consistency, and impartiality, that are essential because they ensure that laws are applied justly and protect individual rights in a democratic society.
-
Judge Culver of the District Court of NSW outlines the essential features of the rule of law and then illustrates what a society looks like without the rule of law in action.
Her Honour outlines a fictional case of an overseas tourist being given a package by a stranger. She looks at differing treatment by the police and courts depending on whether the country has the rule of law and how that impacts the accused’s access to justice.
-
When any of the elements of the Rule of Law are weakened— whether through corruption, erosion of judicial independence, suppression of dissent, or exclusion of certain groups from the democratic process—the foundations of democracy begin to crumble. This erosion can destabilise democratic institutions, paving the way for authoritarianism, lawlessness, or dictatorial rule. This not only undermines public trust in government but also threatens the rights and freedoms that democracy is meant to protect.
-
This poster forms part of the Informed Playing Card Project, showing that with the Rule of Law, all people are under the law.
-
This poster shows how the rule of law provides the foundations for a stable economy by recognising and enforcing property rights with a motivated labour force, investment increase leading to economic growth
Video: The Rule of Law
Overview
The rule of law is quite a difficult concept to define. It means that the law applies to everyone equally and fairly whether government or citizen. The rule of law can also be used to support more broadly things like fundamental human rights and the separation of powers.
Separation of Powers
The separation of powers requires that the three arms of government are separate and perform separate functions and don't perform any function of another arm of government.
We have got the legislature, and they are the Parliament, and they are the ones that create the law. Then there's the executive, who administers the law and the Judiciary that makes the judgments on the law. This is supported by the rule of law because it requires the separation, and the separation is what leads to government still being able to be under law, which is a key concept of the rule of law.
Human Rights
The rule of law can often be seen as the underpinning factor to the existence of Human Rights. You can look to the rule of law as legitimate reason for human rights. The rule of law is often seen as being that pivotal factor under these fundamental rights, such as the right to life, the right to security, and the right to liberty. The rule of law has been used to underpin fundamental documents and organisations internationally that focus on human rights. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights in its Preamble notes that the rule of law is one of its foundation points. The European Court of Human Rights notes that the rule of law is a key determinant in their process as well.
The Rule of Law
There's often a bit of contention as to what 100% fits within the concept but it's generally agreed that these following things are vital to the rule of laws operation; fairness, rationality, predictability consistency and impartiality.
Fairness and rationality really show us that the rule of law makes the law apply to everyone, citizens and the government
Predictability reflects certainty in the law and also certainty in outcome. So if you do break a law you know what the likely response
Consistency means that I can trust that the rule of law is being applied to everyone the same
Impartiality requires an impartial body that makes the decision on any law issues
Historical Background
The concepts that we associate with the rule of law have really been in existence for centuries. You can trace them back to things like Magna Carta and they're quite evident in Aristotle's ideas for good governance.
The rule of law as a term was coined in 1885 by a professor of English of Oxford AV Dicey.
The key concept in the rule of law is that there is equality. We are all subject to the law. Without it could really lead to a government that's above the law and if government is above the law this can lead to abuse of power and a state of anarchy. So the rule of law is incredibly important to how we live our lives.
Related Resources
-
Explains the different ways scholars and institutions including AV Dicey, Lord Bingham, Professor Martin Krygier and the Rule of Law Education Centre define and interpret the rule of law, from minimalist approaches focused on procedural fairness to broader conceptions that include rights, accountability, and limits on power. Highlights how these varying perspectives shape public understanding, legal frameworks, and the practical application of rule‑of‑law principles in Australia.
-
The principles of the rule of law include equality before the law, clear and known laws, separation of powers, and an independent judiciary. The benefits are protection of rights, limits on arbitrary power, access to justice, accountability of government, and a stable, fair, and democratic society for all.
-
The 1951 Communist Party Case saw Australia’s High Court invalidate legislation banning the Communist Party, reaffirming that Parliament cannot declare its own constitutional authority. The decision powerfully reinforced judicial review, constitutional limits on executive action, and the rule of law during a period of intense Cold War fear.
Explore Related Topics
-
Equality Before the Law
Explore resources on equality before the law, including the Lost Parcel story, showing how legal rules apply fairly to all people, strengthening fairness in everyday situations.
-
Presumption of Innocence
Explore resources on the presumption of innocence, showing how the burden of proof protects the accused and safeguards fairness in criminal justice.
-
Independent and Impartial Judiciary
Explore resources on an independent and impartial judiciary, including the history of the Supreme Court & its role in delivering justice & strengthening trust in the judiciary.