Civics: Democracy Year 5-6

Teaching program – Week 4: Equality before the law and Magna Carta

Learning intentions
  • To understand the principle of equality before the law and its origins
  • To apply the principle of equality before the law
  • To explain the rule of law

Classroom set-up for provocation: Classroom rearranged with teacher’s desk or chair at front; on left hand side of classroom - desks arranged in groups with sharpened colour pencils, art paper, rulers, erasers, coloured textas – quality stationery. On the right-hand side of the classroom – remove desks; students must sit on floor, are given scraps of paper & broken pencils, no sharpeners or other stationery. 

 

Provocation: Teacher decrees new classroom laws placed on classroom door. The goal is for students to start thinking about fairness. Students cannot enter without agreeing to them:  

OUR NEW CLASSROOM RULES. 

You must agree to all of them to be able to enter. 

  1. FIRST GROUP: All students whose surnames start with A-M are to sit on the chairs at the desks. You are called FIRST GROUP. 

  2. All students whose surnames start with N-Z are to sit on the floor. You are called LAST GROUP. 

  3. FIRST GROUP are allowed to speak and can work in pairs. 

  4. LAST GROUP can only speak to ask a question. They must put up their hand to do so. If anyone speaks in this group a PENALTY will be given to the whole group. You must do the artwork on your own. 

  5. Using the stationery given, your task is to draw an artwork of our school to give the Principal, so they can hang it in their office.  

 

  • Allow 15 minutes for drawing – the penalty for speaking is everyone in LAST GROUP stops drawing for 1 minute. 

  • Praise FIRST GROUP and ignore their chatter.  

  • If LAST GROUP asks for better pencils, say that the rules say you can only use the stationery you were given.  

  • At end of 15 minutes, discuss the following: 

To LAST GROUP: How did feel to work under those rules? Did you feel like you had a fair chance to make a great drawing for the Principal? Why / why not? 

To FIRST GROUP: How did it feel to watch the other group? Did you feel like you earned your extra privileges of quality stationery, sitting in chairs and tables and being allowed to speak? Why was this activity unfair? Was it because of how hard you worked? Did the rules apply to everyone in the same way? 

Differentiation / Adjustments: Whole class ; process environment

Resources: Our New Classroom Rules poster for classroom door. Enlarge. 

Modelled reading: “There’s a prawn in Parliament House” by Annabel Crabb 

Differentiation / Adjustments: Whole class 

Resources:  “There’s a prawn in parliament house” by Annabel Crabb

Introduction:

Teacher challenges students to think about fairness and how they felt in the provocation. Lead a general discussion into What makes a society fair and unfair? Should laws be fair for everyone or the same for everyone? Write questions on the board and unpack the words as part of the discussion. Split class into two with ‘SAME’ on one side of the room and ‘FAIR’ on the other. As discussion progresses, students can switch sides as their understanding changes. 

 

Put the ‘Equality Before the Law’ poster on the board brainstorm around the poster what it means to be equal before the law. Students copy into books. As part of the brainstorm, define the difference between equity and equality:  

 

Equality before the Law: Focus is sameness. It is based on the principle of the Rule of Law – where no one is above the law. The law applies to everyone (or the law must be completely blind to) no matter who they are, their job, status, fame, gender, wealth, etc.  

Equity: Focus is fairness. Equity before the law means adjusting the support or the penalties so that the final outcome is fair for everyone.  

After the brainstorm, pose this question to students: Should we have a society based on equity or equality or both? 

Differentiation / Adjustments: Whole class discussion; Independent  

Resources: Fabric of Australian Poster: Equality before the law

Activity 1:

To understand the principle ‘equality before the law’, we need to go back in time to England in the year 1215. Watch video – Magna Carta: The Foundation of the rule of law.  

Complete the Magna Carta: The Foundation of the Rule of Law worksheet for the video. 

Show students copy of Magna Carta on board. Look at the handwriting, how it is written and the 4 clauses that are highlighted. 

Differentiation / Adjustments: Whole class; Independent note taking. Scaffold provided to guide note-taking 

Resources: Magna Carta: The Foundation of the rule of law ; Magna Carta – The Foundation of the Rule of Law worksheet ; Copy of Magna Carta

Activity 2: Modern Day Scenarios

Students sit in two concentric circles facing each other. Hand out a scenarios card to each pair of students. Write 3 question prompts on board: Who is in the scenario? What is the problem? What is the outcome? Give paired up students up to 5 minutes per scenario to read card and answer question prompts. After 5 minutes students pass card to the LEFT (outside circle) and then read next scenario. Repeat until many scenarios have been read & discussed.  

As whole class – discuss any interesting points that arose from the scenarios. Discuss how everyone is equal before the law and everyone must obey the law. This is called the Rule of Law.

Differentiation / Adjustments: In pairs – mixed ability. Rotating to form new pairs.

Resources: Scenario Discussion Cards 

Discussion:

In groups of 5, students brainstorm on poster paper both sides of the question: Is the Magna Carta out-dated? Discuss responses as a whole class.

Differentiation / Adjustments: Groups of 5

Resources: Poster Paper

Extension question:

How has the Magna carta influenced modern societies? Using the Legacy of Magna Carter Poster,  

Extension question: How has the Magna carta influenced modern societies? Using the Legacy of Magna Carter Poster, students choose a section and write the script for a podcast. For eg. Habeas Corpus Act 1679. Students think about how a podcast is presented, who should be interviewed and write a script for a 5 min podcast. 

 Differentiation / Adjustments: Extension; Independent

Resources: Legacy of Magna Carta poster  

 

Assessment:

Students watch video presented by the Attorney General. They take notes and then write a lesson on the Rule of Law in Australia based on their video notes. The lesson needs to be pitched at Year 5 level and can use any form of media or format to present the information and key ideas.  

Differentiation / Adjustments: Scaffolded extension questions

Resources: Attorney General video

Key Words: Liberty, equality, rule of law, freedom, justice, fairness.

Outcome
HS3-DEM-01 Describes the origins and features of Australia’s democratic system of government and laws
Content focus

People in Australia have democratic roles and responsibilities

  • Explain the origin of the principle that all people are equal before the law and must obey the law

Related Resources

Explore Related Topics

  • Federation of Australia

    Explore resources on Federation in 1901, outlining how Australia became a nation, divided powers, and established the constitutional structures and institutions that govern today.

  • Democracy

    Explore resources on democracy, highlighting how accountability and representative institutions ensure power is exercised fairly and transparently through open processes, civic engagement and responsible governance.

  • Human Rights

    Explore resources on human rights and freedoms, outlining the key protections, legal frameworks, that support rights, and explore how rights and responsibilities are balanced against government power in Australia.